The 5 criminal profile tiers
- Professional Yellow icon. Violence kept to what is necessary, enemies incapacitated rather than killed, staying undetected. Bonus: incapacitations and kind acts fill the Focus meter.
- Hardened Orange icon. You kill enemies, passers-by in self-defence, without caring about being spotted. Bonus: same as Professional.
- Violent Purple icon. No non-lethal options, enemies and police shot dead, passers-by killed indiscriminately. Bonus: headshots fill the Focus meter.
- Psycho Light grey icon. Many officers killed, defenceless passers-by shot, pets killed (hunting does not count). Bonus: headshots fill Focus, but you can no longer surrender to the police.
- Irredeemable Dark grey icon. Reached by staying Psycho for too long. Permanent, with lasting consequences for Jason and Lucia.
What is the criminal profile?
The criminal profile measures, over time, how Jason and Lucia treat others: how violent and lethal they are, and how they behave towards passers-by and animals. It recalls Red Dead Redemption 2’s honour system. Each character has their own profile, shown on screen by a small horned-face icon whose colour changes with the tier.
It depends almost entirely on how many people you kill. Incapacitating or wounding instead of killing, and sparing police and passers-by, keeps you Professional or Hardened. Killing for no reason, gunning down many officers or passers-by, or harming pets pushes you to Violent, Psycho, then Irredeemable. Robberies and wanted levels do not count in themselves: casualties do.
Moving between tiers
You can move between tiers in both directions throughout the game, except for the last one: staying Psycho for too long tips you into Irredeemable, and that tier is permanent. Rockstar warns it will have a lasting impact on Jason and Lucia. To head back towards Professional, favour stealth, takedowns and limb shots in Focus mode.